i had heard a lot of hype about these as being great quality for a drugstore product, so i picked up my first one in emerald smokes. i was soooo disappointed. i couldn't pick up any color on my brush. i tried all kinds of tricks to pick up pigment, including using them wet, but it didn't work so i ended up crushing the shadows and using them as pigments instead.
i saw a youtube video using one of these quads, and the colors were just phenominal so i picked up another one in natural smokes, and maybelline definetely redeemed themself. the quality of the product was far better than the last one. i picked up the 8 pan version in sunbaked and am continually impressed despite my not so delightful first experience.

I'm not a big eye shadow wearer but I bought this in vanilla and I have to say that i love it. It stays put and has just the right amount of shimmer for me. The other colour choices are nice too. I use mine as more of a highlighter and I think I may try out a few of the other colours later on down the line.

its a great shadow for a great price. i got it in black and really liked it. it was easily blendable and stayed on for quite a while. it eventually did crease (but thats because i have oily eyelids). as long as i touch up every few hours or so..it works really well.