I bought this e.l.f. mascara on a whim at Walmart, because of the price and I wanted to try a new waterproof mascara. While waterproof, I find you need a few layers of product to be noticeable and to compete with other mascaras. I don't think I'll buy this one again.

This mascara had a really thin consistency, and was really natural, not a ton of lengthening or volumizing. The issue with this though, was that it would flake off and irritate my eye.