I love NYX products, I really do, but this one was a FLOP!! There is absolutely no pigmentation in these shadows! I purchased it online during a sale and thought it was such a great deal! Then I got it and swatched the colours on my hand (generous swatches too), and nothing! Just a bunch of dust. You would think at least the dark shadows would be better, but they were just patchy. I just gave it to my 3 year old daughter to play with because she likes pretending to put on makeup. I don't worry so much about a mess because there's no pigment anyways...