Urban Decay Big Fatty Mascara Reviews

4/5
70% OF CHICKS DIG IT
10 reviews
Ranked #741 out of 775 in Mascara

Black
It's big, it's fat-it should be illegal. Big Fatty Mascara creates the fullest, fattest lashes imaginable. Infused with hemp oil to moisturize & keep lashes soft, this thickening mascara takes lashes to a new realm where fantasy & reality collide. The creamy formula thickens, lengthens & glosses lashes. Simply apply one coat of Big Fatty & let dry completely for doe-eyed, look-at-me lashes. For added oomph, apply a second coat. The result? Lashes so luscious, they?ll look like falsies. Packaged in a funky Pucci-inspired component, Big Fatty features a giant, fuzzy brush that separates & coats lashes without clumping. Try it once & you?ll be addicted

Average Price:  $19.00

5/5
Value

Quality

Effectiveness

Recommended? You Betcha!
June 27, 2016


I love urban decay as a whole and this mascara did not dissapoint! No running or smudging & makes a huge difference in the thickness and length of your natural lashes! Also blends your natural lashes really well if you're into applying a half strip of False lashes for the extra bang!

5/5
Value

Quality

Effectiveness

Recommended? You Betcha!
February 11, 2016


Extremely sad and heart broken due to the fact that it's discontinued and they no longer sell this mascara anywhere! Can't even find it online. This was my all time favourite, can't see myself using anything else. Always lasted me a long time and got the job done. Everyone complimented my eyelashes , it was my holy grail



5/5
Value

Quality

Effectiveness

Recommended? You Betcha!
November 14, 2014


When I'm looking to get big lashes, this is the perfect mascara to use. The black is bold, & the brush does a really good job of seperating, curling, & adding volume. The more layers you add, the bigger your lashes get without getting heavy & full of clumps.

4.5/5
Value

Quality

Effectiveness

Recommended? You Betcha!
October 08, 2014


This mascara is great. I have naturally very long lashes, but this mascara really compliments.

4/5
Value

Quality

Effectiveness

Recommended? You Betcha!
November 28, 2013


As a mom things can get pretty hectic, especially in the mornings. By the time two kids are fed, bathed, and dressed I don't always have the time to get myself all dolled up. It's amazing how quickly kids can make you a minimalist.

Even if I don't have time to do all of my makeup, the one thing I refuse to give up is mascara. Because of this I am very picky about the quality of my mascara. Urban Decay Big Fatty is one of my go-to's.

Pros: It slides on smoothly and extends lashes while adding volume. It isn't too heavy.
Cons: It takes a while to dry and clumps easily. It also runs very easy and burns worse than any mascara I have ever used if it gets in your eyes.

This mascara is perfect for adding on top of another mascara to add length. This way you are only adding one coat of it, preventing the clumps. This mascara stays in my purse for the sole purpose of touch-ups.

1.5/5
Value

Quality

Effectiveness

Recommended? Fugheddaboutit!
June 27, 2013


I was very disappointed in this mascara...purchased it instead of my usual They're Real! by Benefit after the clerk at Sephora recommended it, but I have to say it was a huge let down.

Way too much product goes on the brush, it's very messy and leads to my lashes clumping together giving me a look of having 4 giant lashes! I found myself having to wipe off the brush before applying, and ended up returning it because I hated to waste product considering what I had spent.

I know some people really like this mascara but from my experience, it was too messy and impossible to remove, even with high quality makeup remover.

3/5
Value

Quality

Effectiveness

Recommended? Fugheddaboutit!
June 14, 2010


I love Urban Decay, but this mascara is not as bold and bright as I'd hoped it would be. You have to apply it over and over for color to even slightly appear and you can only mildly notice it in bright, good light. This might just be the purple shade (Purple Haze) that has this problem, but because of it I'm not looking forward to trying any of the other shades. I don't really believe it was worth the purchase.

4/5
Value

Quality

Effectiveness

Recommended? You Betcha!
April 07, 2009


I've used this product fr a few years now (new bottles don't worry). I love the volume and the length. Very dramatic without being scary. I do find it starts to flake slightly near the end of the day, but I'm willing to forgive that. It's very hard to find a thickening mascara that doesn't clump. Devoted for life!

2/5
Value

Quality

Effectiveness

Recommended? Fugheddaboutit!
January 18, 2009


Geez. Was I disappointed in this product or what? I bought this product with such high hopes. Hearing that it makes you look like your wearing falsies. I found that unless I applied at least 4 layers on, my eyelashes looked longer. But who wants to sit and apply 4 coats? Without doing the 4 coats it just looked like any other normal mascara. And for the price of $19! That's just crazy. I'm usually happy with urban decay make up, despite their super high prices. But. With this product, I would've been better off buying a normal $7 mascara from any other store. :[

5/5
Value

Quality

Effectiveness

Recommended? You Betcha!
December 18, 2006


I wasn't all that enthused about Big Fatty. It had gotten some good reviews, and I loved everything else I had from Urban Decay, but I was either having a hard time getting past the packaging (it grows on you), or I just didn't believe. Well, I was totally wrong. I do love Big Fatty. It does exactly what I need it to do - excellent thickening without primer. You can build your thickness as well - almost to the point where you look as if you're wearing falsies! And for the price, it's an excellent product.

These reviews are the subjective opinions of ChickAdvisor members and not of ChickAdvisor Inc.