Wouldn't buy again!

I think I have over 10 of these, I scooped them up when they were on sale. I used it once and I do not like it at all. It's super creamy and smudges/creases immediately. The tip is way to thick for any type of liner unless you're going to smudge it out for a smokey look. Color is not the same when it's applied, looks dingy and muddy. Don't recommend this at all.