was NOT impressed at all with ANY of these products. the lotion was far too runny for my liking and the recommended time for reapplication every 2 hours, (40 min if swimming) is to say the least ridiculous. I'm a busy mom with 2 kids on the go. I don't have time to be reapplying sunscreen every 40 min all day long. I tried a combination of both lotions on my boyfriends back (he's a ginger with translucent skin) I don't think I've ever even seen someone burn that badly before and he was only in the sun for a couple hours. if you're buying this product you're wasting your money on a fancy name. stick with the banana boat.