I was kind of surprised to read that people reviewing this eye liner here say it doesn't smudge.

Mainly because that was my biggest problem with it. I rarely used it with primer or eye shadow so I am thinking that might be why it smudged so easily. The color I had was brown and it was such a nice brown and it went on really smooth.

This is a great eyeliner, a little more expensive, but worth it. I love the fact that it comes in so many colours. I have very greasy eyelids, put with a primer, have no problems with this liner. This liner goes on very creamy, no pulling on your eyelids and the colour lasts all day with no smudges. Very good eyeliner.

Best eye liner around !! It stays on all day it doesn't run like most eyeliners .. It makes your eyes pop with its bold black color and of course it comes in many different colors I love this eyeliner

I was very excited to try this product, however I was let down! This eyeliner, did not even last an hour without begin to fade away in certain spots making it look uneven and cheap. It looked fantastic when first applied, the color payoff was great, but it was far from durable. This was a highly raved product, yet did not meet the standards in my book. It rubbed off and became a mess. For the price which was on the higher side, I was let down and will not be repurchasing.

I have been buying these eyeliners for years in various colours and have never been disappointed! As a person with the annoying condition of 'greasy eyelids', it was always difficult to find a liner that didn't end up somewhere near my neck...

These liners glide on nicely; not so soft that they're difficult to control, and not too hard that you have to apply a lot of pressure. The colours are great, some matte, some metallic, and the liner stays on all day! Even without primer! I have slept with the liner on one night and the line was still almost perfectly intact! Sure, they are a little more expensive than some other brands, but in this case, you get what you pay for. As a bonus, they're not tested on animals.

So, if like me, you suffer from 'greasy eyelids', I highly recommend these liners!

I got mine at Sephora and when the pencil low there was no way towharpen the pencil it seemed like
It was a one time use only and that really sucks so I've never used mine again .

i have only the black one but it is very creamy. this is one of the more black eyeliners i have. my only concern is it smudging in my waterline, but most do anyways

This is one of my HG eye liners. It's intensely pigmented (Perversion) and so creamy! This doesn't always last in my waterline, but j do have excessively watery eyes too.. I stock up on these pencils!

For the price of this eyeliner, it is totally worth it!!! The colour glides on so smoothly and is so pigmented, you get every bit of ur money's spent. my favourite is psychedelic sister.

Great eyeliner with fantastic pigmentation and so smooth. It smudges nicely and sets well. It pretty expensive though and doesn't seem to last very long compared to other comparable sized liners. The colour range is great though.