i once got a deluxe sized sample of this in a value set in 2012, and ever since I have been hooked! my lashes look ridiculously long and i promise you, multiple people have been surprised that I was not wearing falsies! Its long lasting, little to no fall out and stays on all day! easy to remove too!

This is my favourite mascara! It doesn't clump and it looks very natural. It also doesn't smudge (I have very oily eyelids). This is definitely worth every penny.

Love this! I usually get the smaller size at sephora, so it doesn't dry as quickly. I have a tendency to touch my eyes, so when i usually wear mascara it gets smudged. With this i don't get panda eyes AT ALL! LOVE.

applies nicely to lashes; also separates lashes very well; no clumping (which is very important when applying mascara) and the brush is easy to handle for lower lash application. Great product!

I really find this to be a great mascara for me. I've tried a lot of brands, but this really works well. I don't find it clumpy and I like that I can layer it to get the effect I want! Another awesome Benefit product!

OMG! I absolutely LOVE this product! The proof is in the name, this mascara makes it look like I have on false eyelashes! Every time I have this mascara on I always get complements left and right. They all ask the same thing " Are you wearing false lashes?" And obviously I tell them "no" and I say its a Benefit mascara called
"They're Real". I just love this product so much I have like 2 more extra back ups!!

I got a sample of this at sephora using my points and I absolutely love this. Be careful of the wand, it's very sharp ! I did poke my eye the first time but once I got over it and gave it another try I started to absolutely love it. My lashes don't clump together or look weird, they actually look long and full and beautiful. I love this!

All the hype was worth it. I received a sample before I bought a full sized tube. Generally, I tend to find not much difference between the drug store brands and the premium brands, when it comes to mascaras. The drug store brands have some fairly good mascaras. Benefit's They're Real blew me away. I have never tried a mascara that increased he volume, length and width of my lashes like this one did and I have tried ever brand on the market. I have always wanted to try fake lashes but am a bit leery. With this mascara, there is no need for fake lashes and it comes off quite easily. I would give this and 11 out of 10. Best mascara I have ever used and well worth the price tag,

This is another mascara I really like. It's a great formula and always makes my lashes look fabulous. The only thing is, is that it's a bit hard to remove. I usually use coconut oil to remove my mascara so it's not a problem when using that, but if you use a store-bought remover, you may have to use A LOT to get it off.

My all-time favourite high end mascara. Best volume, definition and length - you can't beat it. A little more expensive but totally worth it. I wear this on nights I'm going out or have events to attend and want my lashes to pop without falsies.