Don’t do it!

Find that the magic eraser either doesn’t remove marks or removes the mark and leaves a spot behind that you can see where the mark was. Have ruined a few walls even with spot testing

Mr. Clean Magic Eraser

The Mr. Clean Magic Eraser is not working so well for me these days. I would like to try the strip pieces. If you know what I mean. They would be ideal for what I want to clean.

Not the greatest

I think that it is measy and do not last long for soap scum

They work although only for a short time then they fall apart leaving little white pieces behind. I like them for marks on walls but soap scum not durable.

Not the best product for sure!

Its ok for shoes

I bought this for the sake of crayons on walls due to the gorgeous art work my two year old did all over her room and my hubbys white shoes


Shoes look awesome but the walls on the other hand we are now having spots of paint gone and still can’t see this crayon

Extremely frustrating at this point

I think that it is measy and do not last long for soap scum

They work although only for a short time then they fall apart leaving little white pieces behind. I like them for marks on walls but soap scum not durable.

It does remove some stains if you like single use products

I have purchased magic eraser couple of times in the past because of a stubborn stain that wouldn't come off. However, I find it to be a single use product.
Yes, most of the time it will remove the stain but if you really need to scrub at the stains then it takes a few minutes to see how the eraser disappears. It crumbles away!
It might be cheaper at Costco but it's not worth it anyway. I will not buy it again.

I use these on hard to get off scuffs

This is overall a good product to use on marks and tough to get out scuffs. The only thing about it is, it doesn't work on everything. I have used this on many items and it has been effective on getting marks off of the wall, but for other certain products, it doesn't work quite as good. I would recommend it for the quality, but it doesn't hold up for too long as advertised.

Overpriced cut pieces of melamine foam.

Magic erasers are just melamine foam. You can buy it in most places for a fraction of the cost. They do take a lot of stuff off walls, floors, etc though.

I would buy it again

You gotta be careful with the magic eraser..it erases anything like they claim.....even dried paint on the walls! You gotta be careful and not use too much pressure when scrubbing away

I would buy this product again.

This product really works wonders. The only downside would be pricing. The eracers only last a short period of time. They come apart easily after wetting.