Best. Mascara. EVER! I no longer wear falsies because this mascara makes my lashes look that voluminous and long. Love love love it.

For the cost, there are many other mascaras on the market that do a much better job. The formula of this was both dry and clumpy. Mine would also flake off if I happened to touch my lashes. As this came highly recommended, I was very disappointed with this product.

I have a love hate relationship with this mascara. I have days when it works well and looks fantastic. I have other days when all it wants to do is clump my lashes together and make them look like a mess. It's also very difficult to remove. In the end, I've found ones that work better for me for less of a fight.

One of the best mascera's on the market right now.

I LOVE this mascara. The formula is great, long wearing and natural looking. The brush is ideal to separate and distribute the product evenly - and lets you get right up in there - at the base of your lashes to really add volume.

Honestly the most unique mascara formulation I have tried, even with those vibrating gizmos and tube mascaras. It has such a nice, strangely dry consistency that results in buildability but no clumps. Try out in travel size since you have to throw it out in 3 months anyways!

My favorite mascara - so far!

I have extremely short and straight lashes and have yet to find a mascara that makes them curl nicely (yes, I use an eye lash curler too) but I have to admit that "They're Real" gives them a bit of length - or the appearance of length!

It goes on quite thick, which some people might not enjoy but I personally like it!

Definitely worth the extra dollars. The price reflects the quality of this mascara. I would buy it again and again. The other mascara called 'Bad Gal Lash' is also pretty good but I would choose this one over the 'Bad Gal Lash'.

I have used it in the past and thought it was pretty good,would use it again :)

Oh my okay I have to be honest. I love Benefit products just not the Mascara. It is wayyy to expensive, I mean if it did leave my lashes looking "UNREAL". I would throw every pair of false lashes I have and not use them again because that would mean i finally got my lashes to look "UNREAL". The cost of it is UNREAL I would say, the brush and bristles are very harsh, It dries out very quickly, Sorry Benefit, I still love your other products.