We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eye Liner Reviews

Sort by:  DateRating
1-20 of 850

Maybelline New York Eye Studio Lasting Drama Gel Eye Liner

375 reviews

For all the people who love this, I just couldn't fall in liiiiive with this. It's nice they include a brush but for the type of wing I do it's not functional. The gel isn't as black ade id ke it to be it ends up showing up kinda charcoal.
MAC Cosmetics Fluidline

239 reviews

I tried the pod because MAC has some really great products and I wanted to extend the life of my eyeliner. I didn't like how it applied - a bit too creamy but it didn't last.
Maybelline New York Line Stiletto Ultimate Precision Liquid Eyeliner

170 reviews

This seems to be my go to for liquid eyeliner! Its not too wet and very smooth lines and precision. blackest black could be a little darker but the quality is great!
Avon Glimmersticks Eye Liner

180 reviews

This eyeliner is the only one that stays put all day long and doesn’t smudge into the fine lines under my lower lids. They come in a great range of colours - I currently use brown sugar for regular everyday wear but black ice if I’m going out for the night and want a more...
Maybelline New York Eye Studio Master Precise Liquid Liner

144 reviews

I bought this after reading an article stating that this was better than stila's stay all day liner. I opened it and did a wing on each eye. I knew it would take me a few days to get the hang of this applicator because the tip is not freely movable but would seemingly give me...
NYX Jumbo Pencils

113 reviews

so great for eyeshadows. You can apply then after putting matte eyeshadow on, or even layer it underneath a colour to build up the pigmentation. The thickness of the pen allows ease of use, and they last foreverrr
L'Oreal Lineur Intense Felt Tip Liquid Liner

111 reviews

I have purchased this a handful of times and all times enjoy the outcome. It does not smudge , however occasionally at the inner eye corner, it will come off but i noticed if i put a pencil liner first, it stays on what seems like forever! I can apply at 8 am and its still on by...
Annabelle Cosmetics Kohl Eye Liner

95 reviews

Annabelle makes really decent eyeliners. I have been using Annabelle products for over 5 years and always rely on their kohl liners. They are affordable, effective and really fun to use. Over the years, they've really developed their colour ranges and now you can play with even...
Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner

65 reviews

I ran out of my normal eyeliner when I came across Revlon's Colorstay Eye liner. I was leary at first because I only trust my Covergirl eyeliner and this eye liner was a little too bright. BUT.. when i put it on I was impressed to see that the color wasnt as bright as I thought...
physician formula Eye Booster™2-in-1 Lash Boosting Eyeliner + Serum

51 reviews

I was searching for a great drugstore brand of liquid eyeliners and I particularly wanted to find one that's with a brush tip. I finally found this eyeliner from Physician's Formula. Even thought it may be a the pricier side, but It is really worth every penny spent! It's super...
Kat von d liquid eyeliner

22 reviews

I use this amazing eyeliner everyday and it gives a perfect definition to my eyes. Without this eyeliner my eyes feel empty. I love the velvety and smooth texture and it is so easy to apply.
ELF - Expert Liquid Liner - Jet Black

22 reviews

Rimmel London Soft Kohl Kajal Eyeliner

64 reviews

Excellent value and brilliant to apply. I use the black eyeliner in this range as my go to essential eyeliner. Sharpens well without breaking and lines the eyes smoothly with a crisp line.
NYC Liquid Eyeliner in Black

44 reviews

This is my go to eyeliner i love it so muuuuuch. Its cheap, long lasting, and looks good. The brush is a good size and it isn't awkward to hold at all its pure in color and i highly reccomend this eyeliner if you want quality for cheap . Picture is me wearing it 😁
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil in Perversion

23 reviews

I had been searching for a good eye pencil and my daughter recommended it to me so I bought it. I am a welder so it took me a little longer to find out my problem was this product. For a few weeks I kept thinking I had welders flash , my eyes felt dry, scratchy and extremely...
Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner - Intense black

7 reviews

I just recently purchased this liner after years of using the Kat Von D liner in trooper. I find this formula has a truer black colour and no shine to it. It only loses a star for me since it has a tendency to bleed slightly if you aren't speedy enough with your application...
Stargazer uv eyeliner

2 reviews

Easy to use ...soft.. so it goes exactly where you want it to. Dab a bit of color stay eye shadow over the top and I guarantee it will stay until you remove it!...thank you ...love all colors ...was.. exited to try all of this amazing colors...
Avon true colour glimmerstick

1 review

Lovely selection of colours to suit. Pencil not to hard not too soft. Easy to apply and stays put for ages. Available in a range of colours to suit all make up occasions. Perfect addition to your make up case
UZ eye opening liner

1 review

UZ opening eye liner works like magic! I use liquid eyeliner all of the time and nothing works like this! It goes on so easily and looks like I used a perfect stencil! I use the brown-black but it looks just like black! It stays on all day and doesn’t smudge at all! I’m...
L'Oréal Paris Infallible Lacquer Eyeliner, Blackest Black

1 review

This is the best eyeliner I have ever used. I have used it everyday for almost two years now. The product is very pigmented and lasts all day! As well, it is cry proof which is very important for me. Over the last two years the product has not dried out at all and it only cost...