We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eye Liner Reviews

Sort by:  DateRating
1-20 of 878

Maybelline New York Eye Studio Lasting Drama Gel Eye Liner

378 reviews

This is my favourite drugstore gel eyeliner. It has a great, slick consistency and applies very easily. The brown-black colour is very natural. The only place where it loses is star is the longevity. But, as a bonus this little pot comes with a very good free brush.
MAC Cosmetics Fluidline

240 reviews

This is a very nice eye liner. It goes on smooth and it lasts without smudging. However, it is very expensive. I only buy it when I want to treat myself. I also find that I don't get to use all of it before the texture changes. I would suggest maybe lowering the price and...
Maybelline New York Line Stiletto Ultimate Precision Liquid Eyeliner

173 reviews

I love this liquid eyeliner. It is easy to apply and stays in place all day . Its not too wet and very smooth lines and precision. could be a little darker but the quality is great! I would recommend
Avon Glimmersticks Eye Liner

183 reviews

comes in a nice range of colors. are brilliant and I also love that some has a slight glitter to them. It is easy to use and is quite blendable. i like using this product. doesn’t require sharpening so soft on the skin without having a bit of unsharpened wood jab you in the...
Maybelline New York Eye Studio Master Precise Liquid Liner

144 reviews

I bought this after reading an article stating that this was better than stila's stay all day liner. I opened it and did a wing on each eye. I knew it would take me a few days to get the hang of this applicator because the tip is not freely movable but would seemingly give me...
NYX Jumbo Pencils

113 reviews

so great for eyeshadows. You can apply then after putting matte eyeshadow on, or even layer it underneath a colour to build up the pigmentation. The thickness of the pen allows ease of use, and they last foreverrr
L'Oreal Lineur Intense Felt Tip Liquid Liner

112 reviews

I've tried all sorts of eyeliners from numerous brands and nothing compares to this one by l'oreal. The application is super easy and the formula is nice too. No eye irritation so far! I've been repurchasing this eye lineur for years without any issue.
Annabelle Cosmetics Kohl Eye Liner

97 reviews

I go through eyeliner like crazy, so for the price of this eyeliner is good, but it doesn't last long. I find myself constantly having to reapply and fixing smudges throughout the day, but on a good note, the eyeliner does go on my skin easily enough. I just wish it would last...
physician formula Eye Booster™2-in-1 Lash Boosting Eyeliner + Serum

53 reviews

This is another holy grail item of mine! I’ve been using this eyeliner for years and I haven’t found anything that compares. The brush tip makes application extremely easy and allows for a clean flick when I’m winging my liner. The colour stays all day and I don’t have...
Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner

65 reviews

I ran out of my normal eyeliner when I came across Revlon's Colorstay Eye liner. I was leary at first because I only trust my Covergirl eyeliner and this eye liner was a little too bright. BUT.. when i put it on I was impressed to see that the color wasnt as bright as I thought...
Kat von d liquid eyeliner

33 reviews

I really like this eyeliner as its so easy to apply, the fine pointy tip really helps with the application. It also stays on for the entire day but its easy to wash off too!! The only down part is that it can dry up a bit fast if not careful
ELF - Expert Liquid Liner - Jet Black

30 reviews

This is such a great product for the price. The only problem that I have with it is that I have shaky hands and the handle isn’t thick enough for me to grip comfortably. Also you do have to build up the product a little bit for THREE DOLLARS Im not complaining at all.
Rimmel London Soft Kohl Kajal Eyeliner

68 reviews

Not very soft. I find this eyeliner to be difficult to put on. You really have to go over and over to get decent coverage. It is very hard on the eyelids.
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil in Perversion

26 reviews

I love this eyeliner!! It glides on beautiful. It Lasts all day it doesn’t smudge which is why I love this product. My eyes water a lot due to allergies. I would definitely recommend this
NYC Liquid Eyeliner in Black

46 reviews

The first makeup I've ever owned was this eyeliner. I was 13, in a new school and most of the students would wear makeup. I finally convinced my mom to take me shopping to buy a few things, and this purchase has stuck with me ever since. The formula is long-lasting, the brush...
Burt's Bees 100% Natural Origin Defining Eyeliner

6 reviews

I received one eyeliner shade name onyx (would consider this black) and one shade name mulberry (would consider this purple). I normally wear black eyeliner daily. The eyeliner comes in a pencil/stick with a replaceable cap. You can twist it to raise the product up (noted as...

1 review

After using the same liquid eyeliner pen for years I decided to get out of my comfort zone and try Gagas brand. I was not disappointed! I usually don't like tips that are big and really flexible. But this one made making a cat eye super easy and its a cruelty free brand. Also...
Lise Watier Black Ink Liquid Liner

1 review

Over the years I've tried so many liquid eyeliners from high end brands and I find they always fade throughout the day. They don't stay super black. I didn't have this problem a decade ago, and I wonder if recipes are changing. Anyways - along comes this eyeliner which stays...
L'oreal Le Liner Signature

1 review

I love the product it looks very classy. It is smooth and very easy to apply, lasts for long time. price is very reasonable, you just need to scroll to have more No need to use pencil sharpener.
E.l.f Eyeliner Pen

1 review

This eyeliner pen is extremely affordable and works great. It is honestly comparable to high end/expensive eyeliner pen’s from Sephora. It’s a nice dark black colour, it goes on so smoothly, does not transfer or fade throughout the day. It’s waterproof and has a nice thin...