We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
1-20 of 1521

GOSH Forever Eye Shadow Stick

229 reviews

These pencils are great to toss in your handbag and are quite handy for makeup application on-the-go. There is no need to bring along a brush to apply them or even a sharpener since they retract and blend out well with your fingertips. I find that some of these pencils look...
Maybelline New York Eye Studio Eyeshadow Quad

169 reviews

I first tried these quite a few years ago now, and the formula is still terrible. I am not saying they changed the formula, I do not know if they did or not, but sometimes I re-visit a product and like it. That is not the case with this.
Maybelline Eye Studio Color Tattoo 24HR Cream Gel Eye Shadow

154 reviews

I am so in love with these! I own almost every colour in the collection. I like to use them alone or as a base colour to make powder eyeshadows pop more. I highly recommend these shadows. They are easy to use with a brush or your finger!
L'Oreal Paris HIP High Intensity Pigments Eye Shadow Duo

114 reviews

The color looks very bright and vibrant, but it is awful to think of all those animals that had to endure testing just so we can put some color on our faces.
MAC Cosmetics Paint Pots

104 reviews

I love this! I used everytime that I do my makeup, the texture is amazing, the way it looks is everything. I highly recommend to all my friends! I'm happy with this product.
Tarte Tease Palette

43 reviews

Tarte is one of the best quality eye palettes you’ll ever buy. It stays on for along time and it blends really really well! Christmas time is the best time to buy them because you get an entire kit!
L'Oreal Infallible Eyeshadow in Amber Rush

42 reviews

Very pigmented eyeshadow, I recently bought this product and I must say I would definitely buy again..the colors pop I used mine over concealer so I don’t know if the colors would still be pigmented if you don’t use concealer first.
NYX Cosmetics Eyeshadow

69 reviews

This product works really well if you layer it so pretty I used while dancing and it lasted all day ! Would recommend super easy to use and doesn’t crease
CoverGirl Eye Enhancers Eye Shadow

72 reviews

I’ve been using Covergirl eyeshadows for years, they are my go to for a variety of colours. They go on easy and stay put, especially with a little bit of eyelid primer.
smashbox  EYE SHADOW COVER SHOT EYE PALETTE

29 reviews

I bought the Pink + Palms palette as a birthday gift to myself. I thought that since it was a high end product that I would be getting a great quality product. I was disappointed. These shadows have a lot of fallout, they are not that pigmented and you have to really blend it so...
Naked Smokey Palette

23 reviews

This is my new favourite! I love how it applies,and the colour selection. Even the applicator brush is good! Also works great as a brow fill if you just need a little extra!
Huda Beauty Rose Gold Palette

36 reviews

I love all huda beauty! Her products are the real deal. I have this palette, and it's my go to for my night outs. They stay on pretty well thought out the night and the pigmentation is great.
Morphe 3502 eyeshadow palette

18 reviews

I truly love this palette. Got it for my birthday and I have been playing with the colours ever since. Lots of transition colours to use, also you can go bold or subtle for that natural look. For those days when you want to look good but not overly makeup, I use the browns...
jeffree star blood sugar palette

13 reviews

This palette is one of the best eyeshadow palettes on the market. The formulas are so creamy and the pay off is excellent. Definitely one of my main go to palettes.
Stila Glitter and Glow liquid eyeshadow

17 reviews

These glitter shadows are the best glitters I have found yet! They pack a punch of amazing glitter along with colour in many of them. It has greatly enhanced many of my eye looks.
Mary Kay At Play Baked Eye Trio

31 reviews

I love this brand and the trendy colors of the shadows. They are great for blending and stays in place unlike most shadows. I just love not having to fix my eye shadow when I'm out. Other shadows I've tried tend to make their way into the creases even when using a primer. With...
Pür Cosmetics Soirèe Diaries

16 reviews

I like that it’s a natural palette and it colours you could wear everyday.earth colours really make my blue eyes pop.I found though some shades where not as pigmented as others and you had to go over same area few times.But the effect was nice,just had to work few colours...
Tartelette in Bloom Clay Palette 12 Colors Eye Shadow By Tarte High Performance Naturals

19 reviews

I loved this pallets because if the neutral colors. Great quality. Don't really need to use much to get a great effect. Glides on and blends in perfectly
Urban Decay Gwen Stefani Eyeshadow Palette

27 reviews

We all know we love a good dramatic eyeshadow look especially with the looks Gwen Stefani serves on a daily. Her eyeshadow palette Is so pigmented and beautiful colours. The only negative side is they are hard to blend together. Still worth the $ but make sure you take your...
Violet Voss Holy Grail

6 reviews

I really love this pallet. The colour scheme is simple but not boring at all and with the wide variety of colour many looks are possible. The price is amazing for the quality of the product