We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eye Liner - Prestige Reviews

Sort by:  DateRating
1-20 of 196

stila cosmetics Smudge Pot

9 reviews

I like to apply my eyeliner using a brush and have been looking for a replacement to the one I used to use for a while. I'm loving this one, it lasts all day and doesn't end up in my crease. The colour is a stand out black.
Dior Waterproof Eye Liner

2 reviews

Would pay double for this eyeliner. Whoever the genius was that invented this he should be given an award. I have tried all the high end eyeliners, in an epic quest for an eyeliner that could withstand the test of time. And this eyeliner does just that. I have taken this...
Sephora Keep Kohl! Waterproof Eyeliner

6 reviews

C est le mellieur eyes liner ever je suis obsesed avec les eyes liner et cette est incroyable je la Aime tellement est súper súper noir and mince tres recomande
Benefit Cosmetics BADgal Kohl Eyeliner

4 reviews

My Friend gave me this as a gift......I love Benefit , the packaging is super cool and the products are great!!! Does not go on too thick , thinner than it appears and it glids on ....!!!!
Estee Lauder Artist's Eye Pencil

6 reviews

I have this eye liner in soft smudge black and I love the way it applies nice and smoothly. It also lasts quite a while and for many sharpenings because it is not too soft.
Make Up For Ever Aqua Eyes

21 reviews

If your are looking for an eyeliner that is smudge proof and water proof you've come to the right place! I use this eyeliner if I now it will be super hot and humid outside so that I know it will stay on. I also have worn it to the pool and have come home to see that my eyeliner...
Smashbox Cream Eyeliner

11 reviews

I loved the smash box eye liner. It goes on really smooth and stays on all day. It's really a great eye liner. So if anyone wants to purchase this product I would really recommend this to anyone...
CARGO Swimmables Waterproof Pencil Collection

4 reviews

I snagged a gorgeous teal blue from the preview samples CARGO sent us at ChickAdvisor HQ. I love the colour and the crayon is soft enough that it glides on without any pulling or effort. That's all good, but where I think this product truly stands out is the long-lasting...
Benefit Cosmetics Eye Bright Pencil

15 reviews

The Benefit Cosmetics EYE bright pencil works wonders, it works best with other makeup though. It leaves a faint purple, but not noticeable to others. I recommend this product to anyone who wants to try it. It's not a necessity, but it's nice.
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil

174 reviews

Just love how this eyeliner glides under my eyes. It is just perfect to achieve that eye look I go for. You can tell it's a high quality product and worth the extra money if you can't find it on sale !
Sephora Long Lasting Eye Liner

11 reviews

I thought trying out this glitter eye liner would be great for parties and New Years Eve. Unfortunately this is not a long lasting formula and found that it faded over time. Very glad that I didn't pay full price for this product.
Dior Liner Precision Liner

2 reviews

Had a sample and it's just the same as drugstore black liners. Save some money and get the NYC one which is like 3$ in Canada, and even cheaper in USA.
Kat Von D Tattoo Liner

371 reviews

Besides Kat Von D's stance on vaccines ( which I highly disagree with her!) I love this eyeliner. I cannot tell you how many I've gone through. I have tried the smaller versions and the full size and they both last me a long time. I have sensitive skin and this eyeliner works...
stila cosmetics Eye Kajal

3 reviews

This is my absolute favorite eyeliner for the waterline. I have the color "tiger's eye" and I'm not sure what's so special about it, it's just the perfect color. Normally, liner on the waterline makes my light brown eyes looks small and beady. But this color really makes my eyes...
Lancôme Paris Artliner

24 reviews

I got so excited once I purchased the eyeliner but became very frustrated and returned it quick. The eyeliner has a very slippery hold onto it, the brush is way too thick. After struggling with application that came out it chunks, I decided to give up and wash it off.. it took...
Yves Saint Laurent Liquid Eyeliner

2 reviews

I love my yves saint laurent liquid eyeliner so much, it goes on easily, dosent have a bad texture and the brush and package is really really nice. Great price also.
Smashbox Limitless Eye Liner

9 reviews

When my mom started using this product, I decided to Buy it for myself and give it a try since she raves about it so much. It’s truly is the best eye liner I have ever Used. Goes on even and doesn’t smudge. I highly Recommend trying it if you haven’t done so already!!
Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner

30 reviews

Usually on my eyes gel eyeliners are not staying as they were applied . This eyeliner will hold for all day. It has good pigmentation . There are several colours . I have black ink, and it is matte black. Really like this product
Benefit Cosmetics BADgal Waterproof Eyeliner

6 reviews

I didn't find this eyeliner was long lasting or easy to use. I had to press super hard to get a good thick line out of it. Perhaps it would be better suited if you're looking for a very thin liner, but it didn't work well for getting a good cat eye. I had to pull on my eyelids...
tarte cosmetics EmphasEYES Aqua Gel Eye Liner

2 reviews

Tarte emphasEYES in the Teal colour was given to me to try it out. I am not sure if you are supposed to put gel liner on the inner rim of your eyes, but I tried it anyway. The colour is very beautiful and bold! I'm happy to say that unlike the MAC liners that I usually...