We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Mascara Reviews

If you ask any Chick what her #1 Beauty Must-Have Product is, she'll probably answer "Mascara".  It opens small eyes, adds definition to small sparse lashes, and polishes every look from daytime to playtime.  A quality mascara will lengthen, thicken, and darken the appearance of lashes for a bold and sexy finish.  You should replace your mascara after approximately 3 months to protect your eye health and minimize the clumping effects of old product.

ChickAdvisors love accessible brands like CoverGirl LashBlast, Maybelline New York Colossal, and L'Oreal Paris Voluminous mascaras.  Favourite upscale brands include Dior DiorShow, Benefit BadGal Lash, and Lancome Definicils High Definition mascaras.

Sort by:  DateRating
121-140 of 1068

Wet N Wild Mega Plump Waterproof Mascara

6 reviews

I have tried dozens and dozens of mascaras over the past decade and this mascara comes out on top. I originally bought this mascara as I only needed a waterproof mascara for a few days and this was the cheapest in the store. Turns out, it's been the best I've ever used. It...
Hard Candy 1000 Lashes Fiber Mascara in Mermaid Teal

4 reviews

The teal color is so beautiful and hard candy is the only makeup I will use it’s so cheap and works so well it keeps my makeup on all day this is the only make I will ever used
EyeOfHorus Goddess Mascara

3 reviews

This mascara is overpriced. It doesn’t give my eyelashes volume. Puts a little colour on lashes. Had to repeat 3 times to get some colour. However it doesn’t clog and stays put all day. I will not purchase this again
Hard Candy Curl Up & Dye Mascara

11 reviews

wouldn't buy this again, I hated it at first too. But I ended up making do with it, I hate this product on its on. What I do like about it is that if you put it on under a better mascara it's less clumpy. I wouldn't recommend buying this for that purpose but if you already own...
GOSH Cosmetics Show Me Volume Mascara

5 reviews

I have been on the hunt for a great mascara for a long time. Sadly this one did not measure up. Someone had recommended it, and her lashes looked awesome. But I found it left my eyes very dark as it was almost like the mascara was smudging onto my face. Looked like I had been...
MAC Cosmetics Mascara X

8 reviews

It works great, my lashes look thick and dark. It doesn’t clump and feels smooth when applying. I like it a lot better than most other brands I’ve tried.
Neutrogena Healthy Volume Mascara

9 reviews

So I purchased this because my eyes are very sensitive, thinking it would be gentle and it was but if flakes off and does not make your lashes long... if you want to make them darker then yes but longer no
L’ oreal maroon mascara

1 review

I love adding Colour to my luxe since I don’t really wear make up to work. I thought I would try out this maroon colour because I have green eyes and usually a purpleish red goes really nice with my eyes. When I applied this mascara you can barely see it. You have to be really...
Burt's Bees All Aflutter Volumizing Mascara

5 reviews

The packaging was nice and simple looking. When I open it, you could tell the wand and bristles were a rubber material. The formula was dried up. I applied it but it wouldn't apply to my eyelashes very well and it had a very strong chemical odor which made my eyes water. I did...
physicians formula rose all day mascara

1 review

A strong rose scented formula, that performs like an average drugstore mascara. Average spool wand, with a fairly even width along the length of it. Fibrous wand and smooth formula. The scent is just too much for me. Performance was par - no transferring or flaking throughout...
Mascara avon

13 reviews

Good value but not my favourite. Clumps very easily and dries out very fast. Might be good for a young girl experimenting with makeup but not for me. I prefer Sephora brands
Maybelline Classic Volume Express Mascara

1 review

Truthfully, I usually like a mascara by Aldi, but while I wait for it to come round on special buy I needed something to keep me going, and didn't want to pay too much for it. We all know maybelline, it's a tried and trusted brand, right? So, I grabbed this one. Important to...
Max Factor Volume Infusion Mascara

1 review

Having fine, fair and rather lacklustre lashes, I'm a bit of a mascara junkie, accruing quite a collection from budget to high end and while, like with most beauty products and makeup, different people will get different results, I've found it's not necessarily the most...
Elf volumizing & defining mascara

7 reviews

I have naturally long lashes and Elf cosmetics mascara is my go to. It makes my lashes looked more full and voluminous. It doesn’t make my lashes clump together or feel heavy. Love it!!

1 review

I never tried any MAC mascara before. It's worked just fine on me. My lashes looked fuller and curler in a natural way. It was easy to apply and removed. However, the mascara came off clumpy and lasted in very short time. I got flakes after only three hours.
physcian's formula organic mascara

5 reviews

I really enjoy the fact that this mascara is organic and gentle for sensitive eyes but it does not deliver much volume or length which is something that I look for in a mascara.
Avon True Color Super Extend Lengthening Mascara

2 reviews

Ce mascara vaut pas grand chose. Il n’a rien fait à mes cils. Il y a vraiment pas assez de produit sur la brosse. J’ai plus l’impresion Qu’il les mouilles au lieu de faire quelque chose. Je donne aucun volume, coûte trop cher et on peut pas se le procurer seulement...
Mascara sexy pulp de Yves Rocher

4 reviews

Best drugstore mascara I have ever tested hands-down. I love the way the brush is and how it gives volume to the lashes. It is a dramatic but also very wearable for weekly and looks very natural, which is a huge bonus for me. I definitely recommend this mascara
Bourjois volume glamour ultra curl mascara

2 reviews

Got Bourjois Volume Glamour Ultra Care Mascara for a good price and i love the product. Adds volume to my eyelashes and very easy to apply. Pops out more my eyes.
Rimmel London Super Curler 24HR Mascara

15 reviews

•Lengthens, Separation, Curl Hold: 100% effective for me. •Thickening & Volume: Falls short but just pair with a volumizing mascara. •Application & Removal: Easy & no clumps or flakes. ☆Yes I'd recommend for a newbie or seasoned mascara-ist. For full review, go to...